First Published: 2004-05-21

Turks question alliance with Israel after Gaza carnage

Turkish PM Erdogan leads army of critics condemning as ‘state terror’ killings of civilians in Rafah.


Middle East Online

By Sibel Utku Bila – ANKARA

Strategic allies?

Israel's heavy-handed policy against the Palestinians has cast clouds on its ties with Muslim Turkey, the Jewish state's key regional ally, with observers questioning whether their "strategic" partnership is still intact.

Leading the army of critics, Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan Thursday condemned as "state terror" the killings of civilians in the Rafah refugee camp in the southern Gaza Strip.

More than 40 Palestinians have been killed since the Israeli army began its operations in Rafah.

Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul, for his part, warned that Turkish-Israeli relations would suffer.

"The killing of civilians in Rafah and the harsh statement with which Erdogan reacted paved the way for the highest tension in bilateral relations in recent years," the mass-circulation daily Milliyet wrote Friday.

Ankara's warning to Israel came atop other omens that bilateral relations might be on the skids.

In April, a planned visit by Israeli Deputy Prime Minister Ehud Olmert was postponed without explanation, while in November Erdogan turned down a request by Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon for a brief visit, citing his busy schedule.

Following the assassination of Sheikh Ahmed Yassin in March, Erdogan accused Israel of perpetrating a "terrorist act" and angrily conceded that Ankara's intention to mediate for peace between the Arabs and Israel were "messed up".

There have also been reports that Ankara is planning to sideline Israeli companies from lucrative defense tenders, though these claims have been denied by officials.

Turkey's ties with the Jewish state reached a climax in 1996 when the two nations signed a military cooperation accord, much to the ire of Arab countries and Iran.

The controversial deal was followed by a period of flourishing ties in the economic and cultural fields.

Their cooperation has been widely called a "strategic partnership" as Israel lured on its side a key Muslim nation, while Turkey obtained leverage to put pressure on Syria, which was then regarded as an arch-foe for sheltering Kurdish rebels.

Since then, however, Ankara has settled its disputes with Syria and moved to improve ties with Arab nations.

"It is impossible for Turkey to keep silent at what Israel is doing today... Turkish leaders believe that the resolution of the Israeli-Arab conflict is a precondition for combatting terrorism and bringing democracy to the region," said Mensur Akgun, a scholar of international relations.

The government of the Justice and Development Party (AKP), a movement with Islamist roots, is also under pressure from an electorate which is highly sympathetic to the Palestinian cause, he said.

Erdogan, however, underlined Friday that his government's reactions were not prompted by religious but humanitarian considerations, directing his anger at Ariel Sharon, the hardline Israeli prime minister.

"The current Sharon administration takes governmental decisions to kill individuals. And they declare that this will continue. Unless we change this, we can never bring peace to the Middle East," Erdogan told the Wall Street Journal.

"Of course, we are not going change our relations with the people of Israel just because of our approach to the Sharon administration," he added.

Akgun commented that Turkey would like to maintain its partnership with Israel as a fundamental policy, but added: "It is hard to say whether the government would like to maintain close ties with the Sharon administration."

Erdal Guven, a columnist at the Radikal daily, was even blunter in his verdict.

"It is obvious that the 'strategic alliance' is in a period of erosion," he wrote.


Qatar says Gulf crisis hindering fight against IS

Khamenei vows to 'shred' nuclear deal if US pulls out

Baghdad says mission accomplished in Kurd operation

Bahrain accuses Iran of harbouring 160 'terrorists'

Jobless Tunisians seek new migration routes to Europe

Italy busts Libyan diesel smugglers

Fate of IS fighters in Raqa uncertain

Turkish Red Crescent concerned by Idlib humanitarian ‘drama’

US firm to build solar plants in Gaza

Ghost city Raqa scanned for survivors, bombs

Qatar emir calls for talks on visit to Indonesia

Iraq calls on BP to help develop Kirkuk oil

Israeli forces raid Palestinian media offices linked to Hamas

French parliament is set to pass new anti-terror law

Israel says no to Palestine talks until Hamas disarms

IS territory down to almost 10% of 2014 ‘caliphate’

Over 3000 civilians flee Raqa under deal with jihadists

Ideology and objectives clash at Deir Ezzor

Erdogan gets Polish backing on Turkey's EU bid

Iranian guards commander killed in Syria

Fitch Ratings says threat to Qatar liquidity fading

Iran warns EU against new nuclear deal conditions

Turkey activists face trial next week under terror charges

Netanyahu presses Russian defence minister on Iran

US-backed forces announce Raqa recapture

Hollande slams Trump's hardline stance on Iran nuclear deal

Iraq takes control of two key Kirkuk oil fields

US-backed forces retake Raqa state hospital

Divided Iraq tests limited US influence

New UN envoy in Rabat to restart talks on WSahara

Iraqi forces seize Kirkuk governor's office

Iraqi forces seize airport, oil field from Kurds

Saudi Arabia sets conditions to role in Syria reconstruction

In tougher approach, US offers multimillion-dollar reward for Hezbollah operatives

EU ministers join forces in support of Iran deal

Batteries, tape to thank for defeating jihadists in Raqa

Palestinian Authority top official visits Gaza

Israel strikes Syrian anti-aircraft battery in response to shots

Qatar starts to feel pinch from sanctions

Last days of Raqa battles ‘toughest fighting yet’

Omani role has helped Iran but may not do much in crisis with US

Head of IS in Southeast Asia dead

Mogadishu twin bomb death toll at 276

Gazans hope Palestinian reconciliation ends their woes

US-backed forces announce ‘final phase’ of Raqa recapture