First Published: 2006-11-01

 
Saudi study: Iraq a ‘lost battle’
 

Damning analysis says all indications point to current state of civil war, disintegration of Iraqi state.

 

Middle East Online

By Stephen Collinson - WASHINGTON

No comment

The US war in Iraq is a "lost battle" and the violence-ravaged nation's "dire" plight seems certain to see it shatter along ethnic lines, an advisor to the Saudi government is warning.

The damning analysis, unveiled in a presentation at a two-day conference on US-Arab relations here, sees violence in Iraq getting worse and alleges large-scale Iranian "interference" there is set to grow.

"It is already a lost battle," said Nawaf Obaid, Managing Director of the Saudi National Security Assessment project, at the annual policymakers conference of the National Council on US-Arab Relations which ended Tuesday.

The question in Iraq is not "if the US succeeds - it has failed by every single measure that you can think of," said Obaid, private security and energy advisor to Saudi Ambassador to Washington Prince Turki al-Faisal.

"The failure is only compounded by the fact that we just don't know what the endgame is." said Obaid, head of the Riyadh-based independent consultancy which advises the Saudi government.

The presentation was released as debate on Iraq reached fever pitch on the US campaign trail ahead of crucial mid-term elections next week, and as foreign policy analysts here predict a possible change of US direction.

President George W. Bush last week asserted that America is winning in Iraq, where more than 100 US troops died in October, and that political and security progress is being made.

The study concluded that a Kurdish drive for quasi-independence within Iraq would gather speed, as would the insurgency, and Iranian influence in the country could be expected to increase as American influence waned.

Vice President Dick Cheney said in an interview Tuesday violence would go on "for some considerable period of time in Iraq," but argued progress had been made.

Obaid said in his presentation that the Sunni-led insurgency in Iraq showed no sign of abating, that conditions were being exacerbated by Iranian interference and questioned whether the Iraqi government could bring stability.

"All indications point to a current state of civil war and the disintegration of the Iraqi state," Obaid said, adding that Saudi leaders had been trying to counter what he said were US misconceptions about Iraq.

"Unfortunately the assessment is very dire, and we don't think there is a possibility now to avoid a potential disintegration of Iraq."

The presentation claimed that there had been large-scale "infiltration, funding and arming" of Shiite militias by the Iranian Revolutionary Guard.

Shiite officers with ties to the guard and Iran's Ministry of Intelligence had also infiltrated newly created Iraqi army and police forces, the report said.

US Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice meanwhile Tuesday warned in an interview with CNBC against Iranian interference in Iraq.

Iran "does need to understand that it is not going to improve its own situation by stirring instability in Iraq," she said.

"It's going to simply create a neighbor with which it will have problems well into the future. The Iraqis themselves are telling the Iranians that they expect Iran to behave in a neighborly fashion."

Prince Turki warned at the conference on Monday against a hasty US retreat from Iraq, and warned a formal decision to split the country on ethnic lines would unleash massive ethnic cleansing.

"Since America came into Iraq uninvited, it should not leave Iraq uninvited," he said.

"To envision that you can divide Iraq into three parts is to envision ethnic cleansing on a massive scale, sectarian killing on a massive scale and the uprooting of families," he said.

 

Veteran crisis manager Ouyahia recalled as Algeria PM

Iraqi jets pound IS-held Tal Afar

Iran warns it can quit nuclear deal within hours

Tunisia foils plot to help IS seize territory

Damascus International Fair back after 5-year absence

Ankara asks Berlin to investigate 'top coup fugitive' sightings

Iran laments ‘hypocritical’ US religious freedom report

No single pattern in radicalisation of foreign fighters, says Tunisian study

Turkey tells Iraqi Kurds that referendum risks ‘civil war’

Russia hopes Iran will stick to nuclear deal

Israel demolishes home of Palestinian attacker's family

Libyan coastguard threaten migrant aid group

Kuwait reports second oil spill

Algeria President sacks PM after less than three months

Israel detains Islamic cleric for inciting violence

Western-backed rebels claim to shoot down Syrian jet

ICC issues arrest of Libyan National Army commander

Qatar says 'lot of time' needed to rebuild Gulf trust

Oil governor of Iraq’s Basra flees to Iran amid corruption probe

Macron tells Erdogan to release French journalist

Fatwa against Ibadi Muslims in Libya risks igniting sectarian strife

Archaeologists uncover three ancient tombs in Egypt

Turkey arrests Belgian IS member suspected of ‘planning attack’

Iraq, Saudi to reopen border crossing after 27 years

Iran parliament takes step towards easing drug laws

Syrian civilians flee jihadist conscription

Turkish police hunt coup suspects

Conflicts in Syria, Iraq far from over

Heat wave, raging fires take toll across Maghreb

Italy sends envoy back to Egypt after student killing

UN says Yemen air raids exceed rate last year

US troops killed in Iraq artillery 'mishap'

Roadside blast kills 12 civilians in south Yemen

Marooned in jihad: Russian fighters blocked from returning home

Syrians fleeing IS face ‘terrible’ camp conditions

Palestinian Authority releases arrested journalists

Dubai’s soaring property sales boost Emaar’s profits

Iraq struggling to contain its militia activity in Syria

WHO says over half-million affected by cholera in Yemen

Divorces rising to record high in Jordan

Over 600,000 Syrians return home says UN

Will Moroccan Jews in Israel vote Labour in 2019 elections?

Lebanese Army readies for second phase of border campaign

Iranian conservatives tighten grip on Expediency Council

Israel detains billionaire under fraud investigation