First Published: 2012-04-26


How Obama Recycled a Lie about Iran


President Obama has joined much of Official Washington in mistranslating a comment by Irans President Ahmadinejad into the provocative phrase, wiping Israel off the map. Obamas falsehood recalls President George W. Bushs bogus claim about Iraq seeking uranium in Africa, says ex-CIA analyst Elizabeth Murray.


Middle East Online

In June 2007, Middle East expert and University of Michigan professor Juan Cole remarked that bad translations can sometimes start wars. Professor Cole, in this case, was referring to the misleading, yet widely circulated mistranslated remark by Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad during a speech in 2005 in which he is purported to have said that Israel should be wiped off the map.

This old canard long dismissed by Persian language experts as a gross distortion of Ahmadinejads actual words is regularly trotted out by Israeli leaders and their supporters as proof that Irans regime intends genocide against Israel, thereby justifying a military attack on Iran.

However, a literal translation of Ahmadinejads 2005 statement would be something like this regime occupying Jerusalem must vanish from the page of time, a reference back to an earlier statement made by Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, the founder of Irans Islamic Republic, as Guardian columnist Jonathan Steele explained in 2006.

Ahmadinejad essentially was predicting that Israels rule over Jerusalem would eventually come to an end, much like the once mighty Soviet Union collapsed in the early 1990s. He and other Iranian leaders have repeated similar predictions since then, but without any suggestion that Iran would attack Israel. [For more, see "Wiped Off the Map - the Rumour of the Century" by Arash Norouzi.]

Earlier this month, Dan Meridor, Israels minister of intelligence and atomic energy, conceded the point in an interviewwith Al Jazeera. He agreed that Iranian leaders didnt say, Well wipe [Israel] out, youre right, but [said instead] it will not survive. It is a cancerous tumor, it should be removed. They repeatedly said Israel is not legitimate, it should not exist.

Though the wiped off the map phrase is a myth, it has been transformed into accepted wisdom in Official Washington by its endless repetition and remains a frequent refrain of U.S. politicians and the corporate media.

For instance, in an appearance last month on MSNBC, Mark Landler, the New York Times White House correspondent, said, The Israelis feel the window for that [denying Iran the capability to build nuclear weapons] is closing and its closing really fast, and if they allow it to close without taking military action, they would find themselves in a position where the Iranians suddenly are in possession of nuclear weapons, which theyve threatened already to use against Israel. [Emphasis added]

The last part of Landlers comment was an apparent reference to the Ahmadinejad misquote, with the made-up addendum that Iran has threatened to use nuclear weapons to wipe Israel off the map. In fact, Iran has not threatened to use a nuclear bomb against Israel and has even disavowed any intent of developing a nuclear bomb. [See Consortiumnews.coms Sloppy Comments on Irans Nukes.]

Also, last month, President Barack Obama repeated the wiped off the map fiction in front of the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (to considerable applause), all the while assuring his audience of his preference for diplomacy in dealing with Tehran.

In his speech, Obama said: Lets begin with a basic truth that you all understand: no Israeli government can tolerate a nuclear weapon in the hands of a regime that threatens to wipe Israel off the map.

If President Obama were truly interested in the success of diplomatic engagement with Iran, then why would he continue to issue provocative and propagandistic lies about Iran, especially before the start of

delicate negotiations between Iran and the UN P5 +1 (Security Council members plus Germany) regarding Irans nuclear facilities?

Loose talk and inflammatory propaganda can only cheapen the United States international image, inflicting preemptive harm on whatever prospects for diplomatic progress might be in the offing.

The Presidents use of a discredited phrase also brings to mind the careless language depicting a mushroom cloud bandied about by then-National Security Adviser Condoleezza Rice as part of President George W. Bushs effort to whip the American public into a frenzy of pro-war hysteria against Saddam Husseins Iraq.

The late Walter Lippman referred to such tactics as the manufacture of consent.

Hitlers propaganda minister, Joseph Goebbels, called it the Big Lie, that is, a phrase which, if repeated often enough, would eventually pass for the truth.

Having an Iranian leader call into question the legitimacy of the Zionist system of government in Israel and predicting its eventual decline, of course, may be very insulting and offensive to the powers-that-be in Israel, but it is a far cry from a call to attack or wipe out the Israeli population.

This important nuance acknowledged by no less than a member of the Israeli cabinet seems to be missing from the discourse of U.S. corporate media and U.S. politicians.

Instead, Ahmadinejads criticism of Israel has been deliberately distorted, mistranslated and spun out of context into a physical threat against Israel, ignoring the available factual information that indicates otherwise.

Come to think of it, how did such an inaccurate phrase manage to worm its way into the text of President Obamas speech to AIPAC? As a rule, presidential speeches are carefully reviewed by experts at the White House, National Security Council and National Intelligence Council for integrity and accuracy. After all, especially in high-profile speeches, the Presidents reputation is at stake.

The intelligence officers involved in vetting a speech would have ready access to the Open Source Centers translation of Ahmadinejads 2005 speech from the Persian if they had wanted to ensure the accuracy of the Presidents words. Whoever allowed this piece of propaganda to slip through either committed a grave error or had a separate agenda in mind.

This episode brings to mind the criticism of former President Bush for including in his 2003 State of the Union speech a falsehood about Iraq trying to procure yellowcake uranium from Africa a fiction that

helped lead the nation into a costly war and that subsequently brought an apology from CIA Director George Tenet.

In any case, President Obamas gaffe before AIPAC has certainly done nothing to burnish his reputation (despite the applause it received at the time) because much of the world knows better.

Elizabeth Murray served as Deputy National Intelligence Officer for the Near East in the National Intelligence Council before retiring after a 27-year career in the U.S. government, where she specialized in Middle Eastern political and media analysis. She is a member of Veteran Intelligence Professionals for Sanity (VIPS).



Saudi to carry out nuclear power deal with or without US

Air strikes hit Ghouta despite rebel ceasefire effort

Three dead after suspected IS gunman takes hostages in France

US approves $1 billion in Saudi defence contracts

Exiled Syrian doctors treat refugees in Turkey

Iraqi asylum seeker gets life sentence for London bombing

UK says Israeli sentencing of Palestinian teenage girl "emblematic"

Israel ministers welcome US appointment of 'friend' Bolton

Sarkozy vows to clear name in Libya probe

Syria announces second evacuation deal for rebel-held Eastern Ghouta.

170,000 flee violence in Syria's Afrin

Norway proposes bill to ban full-face veils in education

Turkey says EU statements on Cyprus 'unacceptable'

In world first, flight to Israel crosses Saudi airspace

Saudi, US must pursue 'urgent efforts' for Yemen peace: Mattis

US, Jordan launch new counterterrorism training centre

Turkey’s largest media group to be sold to Erdogan ally

Rebels evacuate Syria's Eastern Ghouta

Two Hamas security force members killed in raid on bomb suspect

Turkey gives watchdog power to block internet broadcasts

EU leaders to condemn Turkey’s ‘illegal’ actions in Mediterranean

Sarkozy says life ‘living hell’ since corruption allegations

Hezbollah leader says debt threatens Lebanon disaster

Ahed Tamimi reaches plea deal for eight months in jail

UN launching final push to salvage Libya political agreement

Conditions for displaced from Syria's Ghouta 'tragic': UN

Sisi urges Egyptians to vote, denies excluding rivals

Rights Watch says Libya not ready for elections

Saudis revamp school curriculum to combat Muslim Brotherhood

American mother trapped in Syria’s Ghouta calls out Trump

Syria workers say French firm abandoned them to jihadists

Grim Nowruz for Kurds fleeing Afrin

Sarkozy back in custody for second day of questioning

'Saudization' taking its toll on salesmen

Syrian rebels reach evacuation deal in Eastern Ghouta town

Israel confirms it hit suspected Syrian nuclear reactor in 2007

UN says Turkey security measures 'curtail human rights'

Netanyahu says African migrants threaten Jewish majority

US Senate votes on involvement in Yemen war as Saudi prince visits

What a ‘limited strike’ against Syria’s Assad might mean

Erdogan tells US to stop ‘deceiving’, start helping on Syria

IS controls Damascus district in surprise attack

French ex-president held over Libya financing allegations

NGO says Israeli army violating Palestinian minors’ rights

Human rights chief slams Security Council for inaction on Syria