First Published: 2012-07-24

 

Dutch and Muslim Are Not Mutually Exclusive

 

Social problems, like a lack of fluency in Dutch, large numbers of school dropouts, high unemployment and crime rates and low levels of political participation are still often associated with “Muslims”. Because these issues are connected to a mostly Muslim demographic, many Dutch people see them as intrinsic to Islam and believe that being Dutch and Muslim can’t go hand in hand, writes Marianne Vorthoren.

 

Middle East Online

ROTTERDAM, Netherlands - A few years ago, I had a conversation in a mosque in Rotterdam with two Muslim girls who were about 6 or 7 years-old. They asked me, in fluent Dutch, if I was Turkish. I explained that I was Dutch, and had in fact converted to Islam. At one point during our exchange, one of them said, “So back when you were still Dutch…”

This innocent statement reveals a sad reality: these young children, born and raised in the Netherlands, were already “programmed” to think that people cannot be both Dutch and Muslim.

Many young Muslims who were born and grew up in the Netherlands feel alienated and unwelcome in society, which is illustrated by conversations like this one. This feeling can lead to stereotyping, and a disconnect between Muslims and non-Muslims. Despite this, through my work as the director of the Platform for Islamic Organisations Rijnmond (SPIOR) – the Netherlands’ only local Muslim umbrella organisation, comprised of mosques and grassroots Muslim organisations in the area around Rotterdam – I am optimistic about the impact of a growing number of people looking for positive connections and common ground.

As was the case for many Muslims in the West, the events of 9/11 were a turning point for Muslims in the Netherlands. People who before 9/11 were considered guest labourers, migrants or ethnic minorities were suddenly identified as Muslims.

There is no such thing as a monolithic Muslim Dutch community, however. Muslims in the Netherlands constitute many diverse communities and are not organised under any specific religious institution. Of the Netherlands’ roughly 16 million inhabitants, an estimated 900,000 Dutch citizens are Muslim, with roots in Indonesia, Suriname, Turkey, Morocco and more recently Bosnia, Somalia, Afghanistan and Iraq, among others.

Social problems, like a lack of fluency in Dutch, large numbers of school dropouts, high unemployment and crime rates and low levels of political participation are still often associated with “Muslims”. Because these issues are connected to a mostly Muslim demographic, many Dutch people see them as intrinsic to Islam and believe that being Dutch and Muslim can’t go hand in hand.

To show that Dutch and Muslim identity can go together, SPIOR tackles three relevant issues – the disconnect between Muslims and non-Muslims, perceptions of Islam and real problems within communities.

We bring people together who do not usually meet, both Muslim and non-Muslim, to talk about shared community concerns. Conversations can centre on the need for clean streets, children’s education or caring for elderly relatives. These conversations do not need to address religion, and in fact most of the time they do not. We focus on shared problems, promoting understanding and respect for differences, and finding shared solutions.

Another part of our mission is working on current problems within Muslim communities. Although they do not occur exclusively within those communities and are not caused by Islam, we think it is important to be self-critical and address real issues.

For example, we cannot emphasise that Islam actually supports women’s rights, if in reality some Muslim girls are still being forced to marry or raised very differently from boys.

When it comes to tackling these issues, we use an Islamic perspective to stress the core message. For instance, forced marriages are clearly forbidden in Islam.

We have been working on this issue for over eight years now through our campaign “Joining hands against Forced Marriages”. Of the reports received each year on family violence and family conflict by the Domestic Violence Support Unit in the Municipal Health Department in Rijnmond (the area around the city of Rotterdam), about 50 are reports of forced marriages or conflicts related to partner choice, and there are also cases that are unreported.

Through this campaign, we point out that this problem affects both young men and women. We bring together hundreds of young people, parents, imams and religious scholars so that they can understand Islamic teachings on this issue – which we have found is an effective way to change individuals’ mind-sets. We also emphasise that Dutch law and international human rights law support choice in marriage.

Trust is essential in this work and is our main resource. By building on our relationships with Muslim organisations, we are able to engage many more people. Through this campaign, we also demonstrate that core values many Dutch people hold – equality between men and women, regard for women’s rights, personal autonomy and free choice – are also a part of Islamic tradition.

“Not just words, but actions” is a popular motto of Rotterdam. Through such campaigns, we use concrete actions to show both Muslims and non-Muslims that being Muslim and being Dutch can go hand in hand very well.

Marianne Vorthoren is Director of the Platform for Islamic Organisations Rijnmond, a regional umbrella organisation of more than 60 mosques and grassroots Muslim organisations, in Rotterdam, the Netherlands.

This article was written for the Common Ground News Service (CGNews).


Name see gul
Country USA
Vorthore has a job that cannot succeed. Why? Because Muslim acts speak much louder than Muslim propaganda. Contrary to what Muslims like to spin, the West has studied Islam and formed opinions for themselves. This is an ever increasing phenomenon and does not bode well for Islam around the globe. Some 80 percent of the worlds population are non Muslim and, recently, that percent is growing. Why? Because non Muslims are educating themselves regarding Islam. The sale of the Muslim holy book was high in the West, not because of conversions but because of curiosity and education. We now see the effect this and Muslim acts have had on hardening attitudes toward Islam.
 

Iraq launches massive operation to curb flow of Sunni fighters to Syria

Lebanon Sunni cleric declares war on Alawite militia in Tripoli

British security services gave Adebolajo their full confidence

Niger points at Libya as source of destabilisation for Sahel countries

Lawyer wins one of women’s toughest battles in Kuwait

Intense clashes rock Qusayr as Hezbollah seeks to score points

Kerry: Bashir is trying to impose Islamic rule in war-torn regions

Extension after extension: How long will state of emergency last in Tunisia?

US anxiety grows over rash of sectarian violence in Iraq

African Union sets aside myriad problems for one day

Repatriation of Yemen detainees removes key hurdle in Guantanamo closure

Syria divided opposition struggles within wider Syrian struggle

Al-Qaeda controls villages in Yemen's Hadramawt

Israel, Palestinians urged to make hard decisions

Kerry slams Iran’s Guardian Council over poll candidates

US expands Iran sanctions blacklist

Deadly clashes in Lebanon's Tripoli continue unabated

Secular Turkey curbs alcohol sales

Damascus agrees ‘in principle’ to attend peace conference

Police make two further arrests in London soldier killing

Obama seeks to shape own political legacy

Egypt rulers reconcile with ex-regime tycoons

Algeria’s Belmokhtar brings terror to Niger

Mali offensive opens Pandora’s Box: Qaeda offshoot spreads its wings

Darfur clashes displace 300,000 people in 5 months

Pepper spray charge: New episode in Tunisia Femen activist’s saga

Syria drags Lebanon into another Lebanese-Lebanese war

Mali Islamists take revenge on France in Niger

Khamenei’s recipe to secure his supreme rule: Limit presidential race to loyalists

Libyans in North Africa scared to return home

Syrian refugees head to Libya

Initiative of ‘Syrian origin’ offers Assad 'safe exit'

Cameron: Gruesome murder of British soldier is betrayal of Islam

Is Ennahda-led government waging a mock battle to distract Tunisians?

British FM: Mideast peace process urgent priority

Cloud of cynicism hangs over Kerry’s fourth visit to Israel

From secret to open role: More Nasrallah’s men die for Assad

Six killed in Lebanon’s Tripoli clashes

US acknowledges killing Awlaki

Friends of Syria to step up rebel aid if Assad fails to commit to peace

Mauritanian women denounce violence, rape

SARS-like virus claims another life in Saudi

'British soldier' beheaded in suspected Islamist attack

What is an Iranian drone doing in Bahrain, near Saudi Arabia?

Syria chemicals: ‘Mounting reports’ push UN to renew call for investigation