First Published: 2017-05-08

In Iran’s election, battle is between rich and poor
Iranians’ attitude to wealth, inequality are shaped, firstly, by Iran’s possession of world’s largest combined hydrocarbon reserves.
Middle East Online

By Gareth Smyth - LONDON

Rohani will lose if the election becomes a populist contest rallying slum-dwellers against palace-dwellers

In the first televised debate featuring Iran’s six presidential election candidates, Ebrahim Raeisi promised to triple subsidies going to the poorest Iranians and argued Iran had a rising Gini coefficient, a measure of income and wealth distribution.

Raeisi, a cleric who leads the vast foundation managing the Imam Reza shrine in Mashhad, hoped to present himself as a savvy technocrat as well as a humble man of the people.

Tehran Mayor Mohammad Bagher Ghalibaf likewise described himself as the candidate of the “96% against the 4%,” promising monthly cash handouts of 2.5 million rials — $77 — for any unemployed Iranian aged 18 or older.

Both Raeisi and Ghalibaf — the two main challengers to Iranian President Hassan Rohani from the principlist, or fundamentalist, camp — seek to tap into dissatisfaction at the limited bounce in the economy since international sanctions eased after Iran’s 2015 deal with US-led world powers limiting its nuclear programme.

Of course, Iran is not unique in having a gap between rich and poor. Earlier this year, a report from the World Economic Forum, collating views from 700 “experts,” identified rising inequality in income and wealth as the main factor — along with climate change — likely to shape the world in the next decade.

Widening disparities, the report argued, had not only fuelled populist politics such as the United Kingdom’s vote to leave the European Union and Donald Trump’s US presidential victory but also posed a risk to the world economic order.

Iranians’ attitude to wealth and inequality are shaped, firstly, by Iran’s possession of the world’s largest combined hydrocarbon reserves — 158 billion barrels of oil and 34 trillion cubic metres of natural gas. This gives them a strong sense they are living in an affluent country.

Secondly, the Islamic Republic took egalitarianism from Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, leader of Iran’s 1979 revolution, who pitted the mostazafin (“dispossessed”) against the mostakberin (“oppressors”) and even the zagheh-neshinha (“slum-dwellers”) against the kakh-neshinha (“palace-dwellers”). Hence the republic has widened educational opportunities and improved rural development.

But this has encouraged politicians to pander to Iranians’ sense that wealth is somehow tainted, as seen in Raeisi calling himself a “mazloom.” “Being a mazloom, or victim, echoes Imam Khomeini’s words,” said Elham Gheytanchi, professor of sociology at Santa Monica College. “You can lead a revolutionary nation only if you are a victim yourself.”

In an Iran poll survey in April, 42% of respondents cited unemployment as the most important issue in the election, which is scheduled for May 19. Officially, Iran has 11% unemployment but many economists say it is higher.

“The main issue is the economy, specifically unemployment, and its management,” said Farideh Farhi of the University of Hawaii.

“International relations will factor with the charge against Rohani that he relies too much on foreign investment and isn’t doing enough for the ‘resistance economy.’ Regional turmoil and instability will also factor, with Rohani emphasising the need for continuity, stability and prudent diplomacy.”

The principlist camp has long criticised high salaries of technocrats close to Rohani’s government. Both Ghalibaf and Raeisi well remember Mahmoud Ahmadinejad’s 2005 presidential election victory on the slogan of “putting the oil wealth on the sofreh,” a reference to the mat that the poorer Iranians sit on to eat dinner.

Not that offering inducements to voters has been confined to the principlists. In the 2005 election, reformist Mehdi Karrubi promised a monthly cash handout of 500,000 rials — then about $77 — to all Iranians aged 15 or over. The political class scoffed but Karrubi came in third, ahead of the main reformist candidate who was promising social freedom and political reform.

Hence successive governments and parliaments have diverted energy revenues into popular short-term palliatives, like subsidising medicines and fuel, rather than into the productive investment that would produce sustainable long-term growth.

The unpalatable truth is that any Iranian president needs to make unpopular choices — deferring short-term gain for longer term prosperity — even if these are hard to present to voters.

Iranians may like the idea of the self-sufficient “resistance economy” beloved by supreme leader ayatollah Ali Khamenei but Iran needs foreign investment and imported technology to develop its energy reserves and provide the 8% economic growth that would provide jobs for record numbers entering the labour market.

Rohani has chosen this course and the Iranpoll suggests he has made headway, despite bellicose noises from the trump administration: Iranpoll found 55% of those asked said they thought Rohani was the candidate most likely to “improve foreign relations,” a percentage way ahead of his rivals.

But to win a second term, Rohani must communicate this message rather than just argue with other candidates over who would be the best manager or compete with them in making promises to the poor.

Rohani will lose if the election becomes a populist contest rallying slum-dwellers against palace-dwellers.

Gareth Smyth has covered Middle Eastern affairs for 20 years and was chief correspondent for The Financial Times in Iran.

Copyright ©2017 The Arab Weekly

 

Erdogan seeks to defuse standoff around Turkey’s Qatar

Arab League accuses Israel of 'playing with fire' at holy site

Syria warplanes strike near Damascus despite ceasefire

600,000 Yemenis expected to contract cholera in 2017

Foreign food chains hoping for taste of Iran market

US warns Iran over imprisoned Americans

Kuwait protests to Lebanon over Hezbollah training

30 extremists in Sinai operations

Three Palestinians shot dead in Jerusalem

Nearly 360 injured in Turkey by magnitude 6.7 quake

UN says Saudi to blame for deadly Yemen strike on civilians

Police fire tear gas to disperse Morocco protest

Germany reviews arms sales to Turkey

Hezbollah launches Syria border operation

China calls for Gulf crisis talks

Israel bars men under 50 from Jerusalem Old City prayers

Intensifying Jihadist-rebel clashes in Syria's Idlib

Saudi King sets up new state security agency

Rebel ambush kills 28 regime fighters near Damascus

Turkey slams 'dangerous' Cyprus energy plans

Saudi prince 'arrested over leaked abuse videos'

Israel boosts 'security measures' as Al-Aqsa tensions simmer

Kuwait expels Iranian diplomats over 'terror' cell

Germany vows to overhaul Turkey ties as row escalates

Home cooked meals a relief for fighters in Syria's Raqa

US maintains designation of Iran as top 'state sponsor'

US halting support for Syria rebels

30 civilians dead in anti-IS strikes in Syria

Palestinian civilians urge ICC to speed up probe

Turkey PM opts for stability in light cabinet reshuffle

UN aid flight carrying journalists barred from Yemen

Former IS slaves fight for revenge in Raqa

US, Iran trade tit-for-tat sanctions

20 Yemeni civilians killed in air strike

14 killed in opposition infighting in Syria's Idlib

Morocco sentences 25 to prison over W. Sahara killings

Egypt police kill top militants

Heavy rainfall hits Istanbul causing transport chaos

Palestinians protest Israeli security measures at Al-Aqsa compound

Saudi police question woman who wore miniskirt

Rebels, US-backed Kurds clash in northern Syria

Netanyahu says Hungary is 'standing up for' Israel

Lebanon army to launch operation near Syria border

Morocco delays currency reform amid speculation

Iran parliament vows to fight US 'adventurism'