First Published: 2017-10-10

Kurdish Referendum Roils the Mideast
The Kurdish referendum seeking independence from Iraq has created more uncertainty in the turbulent Mideast with Israel appearing to see value in the new chaos, reports ex-British diplomat Alastair Crooke.
Middle East Online

One week after Kurdish leader Masud Barzani held his referendum on Kurdish independence from Iraq (with both the referendum and independence being contrary to the Iraqi constitution), the blowback has been fierce, angry and almost universal.

A map showing how Kurdish territory spills over into several Mideast nations.

What may have been conceived as a clever ploy by Masuds eldest son, Masrour, to bolster the Barzani familys flagging popularity by posing as a nationalist leader looks increasingly like a misstep. (Michel Rubin ofAEI, hasnotedthat some [U.S.] Congressional staff and leaders with whom [Masrour] has met, came away from their meeting convinced that Masrour sought independence more to be heir apparent, in what will become hereditary [Kurdish] leadership, than out of sincere nationalistic concerns.)

And now, presidential and parliamentary elections hastily called in the wake of the Oct. 3 death of former Iraqi President and Kurdish political leader Jalal Talibani havedescendedinto a mess.Rather than settle the succession upon his eldest son, Masud Barzani may instead have opened a wider struggle over leadership of the Kurdish people.

Yes, the KRG is reported as beinga democracy, but in practice it is run, explains, Michael Rubin, asa (corrupt) family enterprisein which both the Barzanis (and Talabanis) confuse personal, party, and public funds.Rubin explains:Masud Barzani is president and lives in a palace complex in a resort inherited from Saddam Hussein. His nephew, Nechirvan Barzani, is prime minister. His uncle, Hoshyar Zebari, was Iraqs foreign minister and is now finance minister. Masuds eldest son, Masrour Barzani, leads the intelligence service; and his second son, Mansour is a general, as is Masuds brother Wajy. Barzanis nephew Sirwan owns the regional cell phone company which, while purchased with public money, remains a private holding. Barzanis sons are frequently in Washington D.C [where] Masrour Barzani has acquired an$11 million mansionin McLean, Virginia.

The referendum showed that Kurdish nationalism is an easy play among Kurds (but no one doubted that). Though perhaps, by rejecting the universal advice to cancel or postpone the provocative referendum, Masud Barzani in advertently has provided his opponents with just the rope they needed by which to hang the U.S.-Israeli Kurdish project.

While some in the West may see the Kurdish issue as one of justified national self-determination, that is not how it is perceived by neighboring states:It is seen, rather, as a deliberatepoliticalIED inserted into the most sensitive radial node of the Middle East, intended to explode the statehood of four major nations: Iraq, Iran, Syria and Turkey.

A Combustible Region

This is an area so combustible to explosion precisely because ethnicities there are so diverse and because territorial claims on land seized several times over in successive waves of ethnic cleansing are almost impossible to resolve yet regaining those stolen lands remains a passionate objective for those who have been dispossessed.

Kurdish leader Masud Barzani. (U.S. government photo)

And it is not the case that the Kurds have been more sinned against (in respect to ethnic cleansing) than they are sinnersthemselves, as a Seeking Alpha business report explains: the area [northern Iraq] used to be part of major ancient trade route [which] over the centuries was settled by diverse populations. The last to settle were Turkic peoples during the Ottoman Empire Kirkuk, in particular, is problematic as its claimed by Arabs, Kurds and Turkmen with the latter being the most likely to have a legitimate claim.

The discovery of oil in Kirkuk in 1927 and the following boom, diluted the Turkmen population with migration of Kurds from the north and Arabs from the south. The [last] census of 1957 showed at the governorate level that the ethnic makeup was 48.2% Kurds, 28.2% Arabs and 21.4% Turkmens, but that the city of Kirkuk was 37.6% Turkmens, 33.3% Kurds and 22.5% Arabs. These percentages changed significantly under [Saddam Husseins]regime which enforced Arabisation at the expense of Kurds and other minorities, but saw a process of reversal after 2003 with the return of some Kurds but not so much the Turkmen.

Cui bonoby stirring the pot of rival ethnic claims to territory (and 40 percent of Iraqs oil resources), plus the potential fracturing of these four states? Irans Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei on Wednesday said plainly to Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan that, in his view, the United States is seeking to create a new Israel in the Middle East through the Kurdish secession bid. (And Israel has made it pretty clear in ministerial comments that it welcomes and supports a Kurdish state and sees such to be inthe Israeli interest).

Syria, Turkey, Iran and Iraq have been watching events closely, ever since the U.S. (and some European allies) started to set up the 11 semi-permanent U.S. military bases in northern Syria in areas in which the Kurds are prominent but not necessarily a majority.However, with the conflict in Syria edging toward conclusion and with Syria resisting plans for a buffer zone along the Golan armistice line and exclusion zones along the Syrian Iraq border, these four states plainly would not be happy about another, even bigger, pro-Western buffer, inserted right in their midst.

Barzani, however, is not alone in wanting to reassert his leadership credentials, by playing the nationalist card: Iraqi Prime Minister Haider al-Abadi faces crucial Iraqi parliamentary elections next year with former PM Nouri al-Maliki close behind and breathing down his neck.Abadis tough response to the Kurdish referendum has proved popular with his electoral base and has succeeded in putting some distance between the incumbent and Maliki.Remaining tough on the sovereignty of the state will be crucial to Abadi retaining the premiership.

Iraqi Retaliation

Reutersreportson measures already taken: Baghdad retaliated against the referendum with an international flight ban on Kurdish airports, while Iran and Turkey launched joint military exercises with Iraqi troops at their borders with Iraqi Kurdistan. [The] Iraqi government has rejected a KRG offer to discuss independence. It demanded Kurdish leaders cancel the result of the referendum or face continued sanctions, international isolation and possible military intervention.

Iraqi Prime Minister Haidar al-Abadi.

On Tuesday, Iraqs central bank told the KRG that it would no longer sell dollars to four leading Kurdish banks and would stop all foreign currency transfers to the region, banking and government sources told Reuters Earlier, the federal parliament in Baghdad raised the threat of excluding Kurdish members who took part in the referendum, on the basis that it was unconstitutional. The parliament decided to collect the names of those who voted in the referendum as a step towards their impeachment by the Higher Federal Court, Speaker Salim al-Jabouri told a news conference after the session.

It is likely that the four states now closely coordinating will pursue a process of constitutional attrition against the KRG.Baghdad will seek to regain control of the international airports in the KRG (it already controls the airspace); the regional borders; the oil supply and Kirkuk, overrun by the Kurds in the wake of ISISs seizure of Mosul.The four states will squeeze the KRG economically, until the pips squeak, should Barzani try to use the Peshmerga to retain control of Kirkuk and its oil fields.

The strategic shift here, from the past, is three-fold: All the KRG neighboring states are for the first time united in a common hostility to Barzanis initiative (the KRG is landlocked, so this factor is significant). Secondly, that whereas the Kurdish Peshmerga forces used to have a free run in northern Iraq, in the wake of the 2003 war and the subsequent U.S. occupation, now there has been a major mobilization and arming of the IraqiHashd al-Shaabi(PMU) forces.These forces are ready, willing and able, to take on the Peshmerga (the Kurdish militia) militarily in northern Iraq; and thirdly, Russia though keeping a low profile on the Iraqi Kurdish issue does, by contrast, take a strong position onSyrian sovereignty.

Russia, since its arrival in Syria, has been in close touch with the Syrian Kurdish forces (that is to say, the external relationship to the Syrian Kurdish forces has never been a U.S. monopoly).Indeed, Russia has at times used its own forces to protect the Kurds from the Turkish army (i.e. at Manbij).And although Russia does not say publicly what passes between the Russian armed forces and the Kurds, it is a fair bet that the Russians are telling the Kurds to come to terms with Damascus or be militarily suppressed should they try to interfere with the Syrian Armys ongoing recovery of Syrian land (and its oil resources).

Bullied by Israel

So, the keyquestion is how far will the U.S., bullied by Israel, go with this project?It seems that the U.S. government is divided on Kurdish independence and as Michael Rubinsuggestsin his article, Will Masrour Barzani be the CIAs LatestEmbarrassmentand also issomewhat ambivalent about empowering a hereditary Barzani dictatorship.

President Donald Trump and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu at joint press conference on Feb. 15. 2017. (Screen shot from

Rubin writes: What does this mean for the United States? Privately, both diplomats and intelligence circles seem to understand the dynamics of the Masrour-Nechirvan split and, if it is not too strong a term, the psychopathic trends within Masrours behavior.

This refers to reports from international human rights organization of torture committed by Masrours security forces and of prisoners tortured and jailed when they refused to offer Masrour a percentage of their companies among other issues.

On the one hand, therefore, the Barzani dictatorship is problematic for the U.S.sreputation, and Kurdish independence could threaten the break-up of Iraq (which the U.S. is hoping to use to roll back Iran).But, on the other hand, Centcom (the U.S. military command for the region) has fallen in love with the Kurdish recruits Centcom is training in Syria, while the State Department worries more about the big-picture alienation of NATO-member, Turkey.In short, there is no clear U.S. interest (beyond that of Israel).

And yet, events seem to fall into another, forming a pattern.Israel is concerned that it finds itself alone in the Middle East (its only sure ally, for now, being Saudi Arabia).Israel misplayed in Syria.It fears the consequential Iranian and Hezbollah presence in Syria, and doubts that either the U.S. or Russia will do or can do much to mitigate those fears.And so, the Israeli leadership is reacting by escalating its bellicosity (threatening to attack factories in Syria and Lebanon, which it says are manufacturing sophisticated missiles, or permanent Iranian military bases, or both).

Irans Supreme Leaders identification of a putative Kurdish state as another Israel; Hezbollahswarningthat Zionists should now consider leaving the region; President Bashar al-Assads expressed intent to regainall ofSyria, and Ayatollah Sistanis influential ruling against Kurdish independence, all seem a part of this same pattern: one of escalated warning and of new rules of deterrence.

Essentially then, the Barzani initiative has become the peg around which a new deterrence paradigm is being set, and that his referendum ploy has already been quietly subsumed into this emerging regional stand-off.

Alastair Crooke is a former British diplomat who was a senior figure in British intelligence and in European Union diplomacy. He is the founder and director of the Conflicts Forum.



Saudi to carry out nuclear power deal with or without US

Air strikes hit Ghouta despite rebel ceasefire effort

Three dead after suspected IS gunman takes hostages in France

US approves $1 billion in Saudi defence contracts

Exiled Syrian doctors treat refugees in Turkey

Iraqi asylum seeker gets life sentence for London bombing

UK says Israeli sentencing of Palestinian teenage girl "emblematic"

Israel ministers welcome US appointment of 'friend' Bolton

Sarkozy vows to clear name in Libya probe

Syria announces second evacuation deal for rebel-held Eastern Ghouta.

170,000 flee violence in Syria's Afrin

Norway proposes bill to ban full-face veils in education

Turkey says EU statements on Cyprus 'unacceptable'

In world first, flight to Israel crosses Saudi airspace

Saudi, US must pursue 'urgent efforts' for Yemen peace: Mattis

US, Jordan launch new counterterrorism training centre

Turkey’s largest media group to be sold to Erdogan ally

Rebels evacuate Syria's Eastern Ghouta

Two Hamas security force members killed in raid on bomb suspect

Turkey gives watchdog power to block internet broadcasts

EU leaders to condemn Turkey’s ‘illegal’ actions in Mediterranean

Sarkozy says life ‘living hell’ since corruption allegations

Hezbollah leader says debt threatens Lebanon disaster

Ahed Tamimi reaches plea deal for eight months in jail

UN launching final push to salvage Libya political agreement

Conditions for displaced from Syria's Ghouta 'tragic': UN

Sisi urges Egyptians to vote, denies excluding rivals

Rights Watch says Libya not ready for elections

Saudis revamp school curriculum to combat Muslim Brotherhood

American mother trapped in Syria’s Ghouta calls out Trump

Syria workers say French firm abandoned them to jihadists

Grim Nowruz for Kurds fleeing Afrin

Sarkozy back in custody for second day of questioning

'Saudization' taking its toll on salesmen

Syrian rebels reach evacuation deal in Eastern Ghouta town

Israel confirms it hit suspected Syrian nuclear reactor in 2007

UN says Turkey security measures 'curtail human rights'

Netanyahu says African migrants threaten Jewish majority

US Senate votes on involvement in Yemen war as Saudi prince visits

What a ‘limited strike’ against Syria’s Assad might mean

Erdogan tells US to stop ‘deceiving’, start helping on Syria

IS controls Damascus district in surprise attack

French ex-president held over Libya financing allegations

NGO says Israeli army violating Palestinian minors’ rights

Human rights chief slams Security Council for inaction on Syria