First Published: 2017-10-30

It’s not Enough to Wish ISIS fighters Dead
Clearly, there is an urgent need to prepare for the likelihood of the fighters’ return to the West. This must be by rule of law, observes Rashmee Roshan Lall.
Middle East Online

A British government minister recently addressed the unique international difficulties posed by the Islamic State’s loss of territory and the shrinking of the country it audaciously named after itself. In that harsh line, he laid bare the complexities of the case. With the Islamic State’s defeat, the foreign fighters who pledged their troth to the brutal extremist group would want to return home. What should their home countries do with them? What could they do about them and for them?

The answer, British minister Rory Stewart said, is to wish fervently for their death. It is better, he said of the estimated 400 Britons with the Islamic State (ISIS), “to be serious about the fact these people are a serious danger to us and, unfortunately, the only way of dealing with them will be, in almost every case, to kill them.”

The uncompromising stance may have seemed surprising from Stewart. A former diplomat who served in Iraq, Stewart is an intrepid and empathetic travel writer. He has walked through Pakistan, Iran, Afghanistan and Libya and run a charitable crafts association in Afghanistan. He is one of the few in Western public life to acknowledge that the 2003 Iraq invasion had been an almighty mistake. If anyone might see the grey in a seemingly black-and-white situation, Stewart would be the one.

And yet Stewart isn’t much of an outlier among Western officials. Just days earlier, French Defence Minister Florence Parly spelt out her hopes for the fighters, more of whom joined ISIS from France than any other Western European country. “If the jihadis perish in this fight, I would say that’s for the best,” she said.

The American opinion was summed up by Brett McGurk, special presidential envoy for the global anti-ISIS coalition. “Our mission is to make sure that any foreign fighter who is here, who joined ISIS from a foreign country and came into Syria, they will die here in Syria,” he said.

The terms of the debate are blunt. The West doesn’t want extremist nationals back. It would rather they conveniently perish on the battlefield than have to deal with repatriation. The anti-ISIS coalition has given names and photos of Western fighters to the Kurds. One People’s Protection Units (YPG) official was quoted as saying they would be “eliminated.” Even so, there is the chance some foreign jihadists will escape. There is the possibility they will be forcibly returned to the coalition, after which, repatriation is the only option.

Though the West has been the most voluble, governments in the Middle East and North Africa and in Muslim countries in South-east Asia face the same challenges. A report by the Soufan Group and the Global Strategy Network said the contours of the problem are troublingly vague but clear nonetheless. At least 5,600 ISIS fighters from 33 countries have gone home. That includes 900 Turks, 800 Tunisians and some 760 Saudis. Approximately 20-30% of the European jihadists have returned, though it’s 50% of those from Britain, Denmark and Sweden.

The report, titled “Beyond the Caliphate: Foreign Fighters and the Threat of Returnees,” said Libya and the Philippines are particularly vulnerable to the reverse flow from ISIS’s failed caliphate. With their own returning citizens come other fighters, seeking refuge in or revenge out of Muslim countries.

Statistically speaking, it’s a big problem. From 2011, more than 40,000 foreigners from more than 110 countries travelled to join ISIS. A mere 7,400 were Westerners, 5,000 of them from Europe.

Obviously, it would be for the best, “the preferred resolution,” in the words of Bruce Hoffman, director of Georgetown University’s Security Studies Programme, if they didn’t return. “What worries me,” Hoffman added, “is I think it’s wishful thinking that they’re all going to be killed off.”

Clearly, there is an urgent need to prepare for the likelihood of the fighters’ return. This must be by rule of law. In Europe, where the death penalty has been abolished, they would have to be tried (possibly for treason as well as criminal activity) and in some cases, the obviously brainwashed and repentant would need to be rehabilitated.

The Soufan report acknowledged the defects in each approach. Incarceration risks further radicalisation or the radicalisation of fellow inmates, it said. Also, rehabilitation and reintegration is hard, especially when many fighters “were never integrated in the first place.”

The solution is not as obvious as the scale of the problem but this much is evident: It’s not enough to wish ISIS fighters dead.

Rashmee Roshan Lall is a regular columnist for The Arab Weekly. She blogs at and is on Twitter @rashmeerl

Copyright ©2017 The Arab Weekly


UN Security Council lenient to Turkey’s Syria offensive

Washington probes Hezbollah ‘narcoterrorism’

Tillerson to present US strategy on Syria to European, Arab allies

Russia pension funds may invest in Aramco IPO

Iranian woman skydiver looks to break down stereotypes

Palestinians in occupied West Bank get 3G

Turkish army clashes with Kurdish militia amid US alarm

Turkey arrests dozens accused of ‘terror propaganda’

Three French female jihadists face possible death penalty in Iraq

Women journalists protest separation during Pence visit to Jerusalem

Egypt military accuses presidential hopeful of committing crimes

Israeli minister calls to ban author praising Palestinian teen

Qatar supports Turkey’s offensive against Kurds

World powers meet on Syria chemical attacks

Morocco's king appoints five new ministers

Pence pledges US embassy move by end of 2019 on Jerusalem trip

Russia calls for diplomatic solution to Yemen conflict

Russia invites Kurds to join Syria peace process

Turkey shells Kurdish targets in northern Syria

Closer look at pro-Ankara rebels amassing around Afrin

Pence set for Palestinian snub

Abbas to ask EU to recognise Palestinian state

Saudi-led coalition to give $1.5 bln in Yemen aid

Mattis: Turkey gave US advance warning on Syria operation

Yemen releases budget for first time in three years

Saudi calls for cooperation between OPEC, non-OPEC countries

France presses Turkey to end offensive against Kurds

The changing faces of al-Qaeda in Syria

Kurdish militia fire rockets at Turkish town

Moroccans wary depreciation of dirham could raise cost of living, despite benefits

Deserted streets, terrified civilians after Turkey attacks Afrin

Iraqi, Kurdish leaders hold talks on bitter regional dispute

Russia-led Syria peace congress to be held January 30

Turkey launches new strikes on Kurdish targets in Syria

Egypt's Sisi says will stand for re-election

Pence heads to Mideast despite Muslim, Christian anger

Assad regime says Syria a 'tourist' destination

Journalists arrested while reporting Sudan protests

Aid for millions of Palestinians hostage to politics

Lebanon thwarts holiday attacks using IS informant

Mortar fire wounds 14 in Syria mental hospital

Turkish military fires on Kurdish forces in Syria's Afrin

More than 32,000 Yemenis displaced in intensified fighting

UN warns of "lost generation" in South Sudan's grinding conflict

Saudi's refined oil exports offset crude curbs