First Published: 2017-12-20

Trump Driven by Ego, the Iranians and Turks by Own Agendas on Jerusalem
Trumps claim that he could negotiate between the antagonists is about as outside the realm of possibilities as can be, observes Claude Salhani.
Middle East Online

Will US President Donald Trumps highly controversial decision to recognise Jerusalem as the capital of Israel and to move the US Embassy from Tel Aviv provide the spark needed to revive peace negotiations between Israelis and Palestinians?

Will it wake up the Palestinians from their political slumber?

Will it make the Israelis realise that they cannot go on occupying another people indefinitely?

Or will that spark flare the other way and reignite violence in the region?

Pundits have been divided on the answers to those questions, with some asking whether the American presidents decision may offer an opportunity for a real game changer. Wishful thinking, say the pessimists and the realists.

Trump stated that his directive was an overdue acknowledgement of the facts on the ground. Because Jerusalem is the seat of the Israeli government, should it not be recognised as such by the international community?

Practically all world leaders, including many close US allies, condemned Trumps decision and reaffirmed that the status of Jerusalem should be decided during peace talks between the Israelis and Palestinians. Trumps initiative could revitalise Arab and European sympathy for Palestinian sentiments throughout the world, resulting in a political setback for Israel.

Trumps claim that he could negotiate between the antagonists is about as outside the realm of possibilities as can be. He does not realise the complexity of the problem. The Middle East issue has over the decades stomped US presidents Jimmy Carter, Bill Clinton and others and a slew of conflict resolution experts from Gunnar Jarring to George Mitchell. All have failed. For Trump to succeed would be nothing short of a miracle.

Much of the debate has to do with the perception of Trump and the controversies he systematically sparks, not about the policy itself. There is really nothing new here as previous US presidents, including Barack Obama and George W. Bush, announced their recognition of Jerusalem as the site for the US Embassy in Israel even if they refrained from announcing its transfer.

Can such a move force the Trump administration to be more forthcoming with the Palestinians? That again is highly unlikely as Trumps positions are often driven by his inflated ego. His Jerusalem plan dimmed the prospects of peaceful dialogue and pushed the Palestinians moderate leadership towards unprecedented extremes.

One certainty is going to be the rise of Iranian interference in Lebanese politics and consequently more activity along Israels northern frontier.

This points to another aspect of the possible ripple effects of the Jerusalem crisis. A recent declaration by Hezbollah hinted at the border between Israel and Lebanon becoming a flashpoint of violence. The pro-Iranian forces have come a long way since their last round of fighting with Israel a few summers ago. Hezbollah is better equipped, better trained and its fighters have had several years of combat experience fighting in support of Syrian President Bashar Assad.

There is little doubt that Iran and its proxies in the region will milk the Jerusalem issue, hoping to extract whatever political mileage they can from the developments. That seems to be the endgame of Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, who has engaged in all sorts of inciteful theatrics for the sake of creating a wider base of support among Islamist supporters at home and in the region.

Public opinion in the Arab and Muslim worlds seem, however, to have grown more realistic if not fatalistic since the Arab springs catastrophic process in the region.

The bottom line is that in an attempt to restore its deeply frayed legitimacy in Lebanon and elsewhere since its intervention in Syria, Hezbollah could be tempted to open a front with Israel. That is likely, however, to be an Iran-supported sectarian front at best. The Arab world is busy extinguishing its fires.

Claude Salhani is the Opinion section editor of The Arab Weekly.

Copyright 2017 The Arab Weekly


UN in security talks with Syria on chemical probe

Libya to clamp down on fuel smuggling

In Iraq's oil-rich Basra, shanty towns flourish

Riyadh says two al Qaeda militants killed in Yemen

Saudi women embrace sports headscarves

Turkey sentences 18 to life for killing ‘hero’ coup soldier

Exxon faces setback in Iraq as oil and water mix

Yemen to arrest colonel for overlooking African migrant rape

Erdogan sends Turkey to snap polls on June 24

Qatar joins Gulf military exercise in apparent compromise

Saudi-Russia oil alliance likely to undercut OPEC

Record of women candidates in Lebanon, but you can't tell from TV

Sudan protests to UN over Egypt voting in disputed area

Erdogan calls Turkey snap polls for June 24

Rights watchdog say African migrants face rape, torture in Yemen

Nine years since last vote, Lebanon in election fever

Israeli fire neat Gaza border injures five Palestinian

Egypt army says killed jihadist leader in Sinai

Iraq sentences over 300 people to death for IS links

Syria chemical weapons visit delayed after gunfire

Syria regime shells last jihadist pockets in Damascus

After the war is won, ‘we shall not return’ to Mosul

Saudi Arabia to host cinema test screening with 'Black Panther'

Trump voices support for US pastor jailed in Turkey

Rouhani says Iran will make or buy any weapons it needs

US fears ceding influence to Russia, Iran in Syria

Nationalist Erdogan ally calls for snap Turkey elections

Saudi renews offer to deploy troops to Syria

Kaveh Madani, Iran’s expat eco-warrior who was on too many fronts

UN to launch new Yemen plan to restart negotiations

Russia dismisses West's 'untimely' push on Syria

Turkey, Iran to press on with Russia alliance on Syria

Iraq sentences French IS member to life in jail

Inspection of Syria chemical attack scene in limbo

Golan Druze rally in support of Syria's Assad

Macron admits Syria strikes ‘solve nothing’

Rebels, regime agree new deal for exit from Syrian town

Syria retracts ‘false alarm’ missile attack report

Gulf split deepens in Somalia's Puntland region

MENA countries must spend $260 billion to meet power demands

Kuwaiti crown prince heads to the US for medical tests

Arab leaders unlikely to act on US Jerusalem move

EU to start talks with Morocco on new fishing deal inclusive of Western Sahara

Saudi-led coalition warns of 'painful' response over Yemen drones

France seeks to revoke Assad's Legion of Honour