First Published: 2006-06-14

Evidence from Gaza beach points to Israeli shell

HRW’s military analyst is certain blast that killed 8 civilians in Gaza beach caused by 155mm shell used by Israeli military.


Middle East Online

Israeli hands in the murder of Palestinian civilians in Gaza beach

GAZA CITY - Evidence from a Gaza beach where a blast killed eight civilians over the weekend indicates an Israeli shell caused the deaths despite denials from the military, a Human Rights Watch researcher who examined the site said Wednesday.

"The Israelis stated that the shrapnel removed from victims in Israel was not artillery shrapnel but they offered up no alternative explanation of what it is," said Marc Garlasco, a former Pentagon advisor who now works as a military analyst for the New York-based rights group.

But Garlasco said that after examining shrapnel from the scene and studying victims' wounds he concluded that the blast was caused by a 155mm shell, which is used by the Israeli military.

"We are very certain that it is a 155mm shell," he said.

Garlasco's conclusions are at odds with findings of the Israeli military.

"This shrapnel was not from a 155mm... there is no doubt on this point," General Meir Klifi, who is heading an internal investigation into the explosion, told public radio Wednesday, adding that the inquiry was ongoing.

The previous day Israeli chief of staff General Dan Halutz told reporters that the military did not "bear responsibility" for the deaths.

Unlike HRW, the Israeli military has not examined the site of the blast, which drew worldwide condemnation, and is relying on intelligence, examination of victims treated in Israel and analysis of television images of the beach.

Garlasco said that he had offered to share evidence that he gathered at the beach with the military.

"Our office in Jerusalem has been in contact with the IDF, they're trying to facilitate meetings, I'm very hopeful that we'll have an exchange of information," he said.

The military has suggested that the blast could have been caused by a mine planted by Palestinian militants at the beach to thwart operations by Israeli special forces.

Garlasco dismissed the suggestion.

"It's so obviously not a landmine that I was surprised the Israelis went down that road," he said.

UN Secretary General Kofi Annan was equally sceptical about such claims, describing them as "odd."


Syria Kurds vow to cleanse enclave from Turkish 'scourges'

US withholds $65 million from UN agency for Palestinians

Saudi Arabia intercepts new Yemen rebel missile attack

Britain to put women at heart of peace work in Iraq, Nigeria, South Sudan

Bitcoin appeal beats ban and warnings in Jordan

Iran says Trump jeopardising Airbus deals

China says Iranian oil tanker wreck located

Sudan arrests communist leader after protests

Syrian opposition joins condemnation of US 'border force'

Israeli judge detains teen until trial for viral ‘slap video’

Arab league slams US freeze of Palestinian funding

Dubai billionaire to sell 15 percent Damac stake

Saudi to give Yemen government $2bn bailout

Israeli police find missing Briton’s belongings in desert

Algeria gas plant workers mark five years since jihadist siege

UN says over 5000 children killed or injured in Yemen war

European leaders’ response to Iran protests raises questions

Erdogan to visit Pope Francis next month

Iran slams US-backed 'border security force' in Syria

Palestinian suspension of Israel recognition unlikely for now

Jordan to hike fuel, bread prices

Yemen rebels free journalist detained since August

Palestinian reconciliation brings no change for Gazans

Sudan police use force, tear gas against protesters

Both hardliners and moderates have failed Iranians

Erdogan says Turkish military op in Syria's Afrin to be supported by rebels

UAE to lodge complaint over Qatar flight 'interception'

UN says 22 million Yemenis in need of aid

Minorities in north Iraq look to post-jihadist future

US-purchased cranes arrive at Yemen rebel-held port

Palestinian leaders call for suspension of recognition of Israel

Morocco dirham stable after flexible FX system introduction

10 killed in clashes at Tripoli airport

Sisi vows to protect Egypt's water supply

Palestinians meet to respond to Trump's 'slap of the century'

Hezbollah’s popular support jeopardises Lebanon’s alliances

European judicial opinion could deal fresh blow to Brussels-Rabat ties

Turkey plane plunged off runway due to ‘engine surge’

Iran oil tanker's sinking off China raises environmental fears

Protests held on Tunisia uprising anniversary

Double suicide bombing shakes in Baghdad

Iranian oil tanker sinks engulfed in flames

Will Abdullah Gul challenge Erdogan?

Hamas official wounded in car bomb attack in Lebanon

Iraqi PM Abadi announces candidacy for May elections