First Published: 2007-05-21

The US-Iranian Duel Enters a New Phase

Both the United States and Iran should end their propaganda war and get down to serious talks. They need to resume diplomatic relations so as to allow for wider and more sustained contact, argues Patrick Seale.


Middle East Online

In the first public, high-level, face-to-face talks since 1980, American and Iranian envoys are due to meet in Baghdad on 28 May to discuss the security situation in Iraq. This important development signals a shift in both US and Iranian policy. It is almost an admission that they need each other. The road to reconciliation, however, is likely to be long and hard.

The climate for a fruitful dialogue has been soured by the arrest and incarceration in Tehran’s Evin prison of a prominent Iranian-American academic, Haleh Esfandiari, head of the Middle East program at the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars -- one of the rare non-partisan think-tanks in Washington.

The paradox is that Dr Esfandiari, who has lived in the United States for the past 26 years, has been a consistent advocate of US-Iranian dialogue. She had come to Tehran to visit her 93-year old sick mother. On her way back to the airport last December, she was stopped by masked men, placed under house arrest, interrogated at length by the intelligence services and imprisoned on 2 May on a charge of threatening national security.

She may be a victim of a struggle in Iran between moderates and hard-liners. Her arrest has severely damaged Iran’s reputation in the West -- hardly a situation Iran might welcome in its current propaganda war with the United States.

Iran and the United States are at odds over subjects ranging from Iraq to Iran’s nuclear ambitions. The US has a desperate need to stabilize the situation in Iraq. It is anxious to reduce the daily death toll of its troops; to stop the hemorrhage of funds (running at about $9bn a month); to convince opinion in the US that President George W. Bush’s policies are succeeding; and above all to salvage from the catastrophic war and occupation some degree of influence in a strategically vital country which sits on top of the second or third largest oil reserves in the world.

Iran’s interests are very different. It is anxious to secure international recognition that the political order in Iraq will henceforth be dominated by the majority Shi‘a community -- the first time this has happened since Britain created the modern Iraqi state under Sunni leadership in 1920-21.

Iran suspects the United States of trying to bring the Iraqi Ba‘thists back on to the political scene, the same hated Ba‘thists who fought Iran to a standstill in an eight-year war (1980-88) at a cost of perhaps one million dead. Iran’s ambition is to see the emergence of a stable -- but not too strong -- Iraqi state under friendly Shi‘a leadership.

Iran believes this can best be achieved by the withdrawal from Iraq and the Gulf of the American military presence, which it blames for causing chaos as well as fuelling a Shi‘a-Sunni war.

Both Iran and the US have been courting the Gulf States. Iran’s President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad paid a historic visit to the United Arab Emirates earlier this month, hot on the heels of a visit by US Vice President Dick Cheney. Ahmadinejad called for a tightening of Iran’s already close trade ties with the Emirates, whereas Cheney’s tone was threatening, warning Iran that the US would not allow it to block the oil flow through the Gulf or to acquire nuclear weapons.

Iran is expanding its uranium enrichment plant at Natanz for what it claims are purely peaceful purposes -- as it is fully entitled to do under the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty. But the US suspects that Iran’s civilian nuclear activities are a cover for a secret military programme. "All options are on the table," the US has often said -- a veiled reference to a possible resort to military action. According to a recent poll, 71 per cent of Israelis would favour a US military attack on Iran if diplomacy fails to halt its nuclear activities.

No doubt bowing to pressure from AIPAC -- Israel’s lobby in the US -- Barack Obama, a Democratic presidential hopeful, has introduced the Iran Sanctions Enabling Act in the US Senate which would require the Federal Government to publish a list of companies investing more than $20m in Iran’s energy sector. A similar bill is being presented in the House of Representatives by New York Congressman Barney Frank.

As Iran has ignored the UN deadline to suspend uranium enrichment, President Bush last week threatened Iran with stiffer sanctions under a third UN Security Council Resolution now being drafted. Meanwhile, however, Ali Larijani, Iran’s chief nuclear negotiator, is to meet Javier Solana, the European Union’s foreign policy chief, for a new round of talks on 31 May.

As if to blunt criticism of Iran in the US and Israel, Larijani declared this week that Iran had no intention of destroying Israel and that the allegation that it was planning to "wipe Israel from the map" was an invention of the Western media. The prompt release by Iran of Dr. Haleh Esfandiari would also greatly improve the climate for negotiations.

Both the United States and Iran should end their propaganda war and get down to serious talks. They need to resume diplomatic relations so as to allow for wider and more sustained contact. The US is at a grave disadvantage by not having a diplomatic presence in Tehran.

Patrick Seale is a leading British writer on the Middle East, and the author of The Struggle for Syria; also, Asad of Syria: The Struggle for the Middle East; and Abu Nidal: A Gun for Hire.


Pentagon skeptical about Russia's Syria pullout claims

Senior Saudi prince blasts Trump's "opportunistic" Jerusalem move

Kuwait ruler’s son named defence minister

EU accused of complicity in Libya migrant rights violations

Saudi Arabia lifts decades-long ban on cinemas

Israeli sentenced to four years for arson attack on church

Erdogan risks sabotaging fragile relations with Israel

6.2-magnitude earthquake strikes Iran

Two Gazans killed by Israeli ‘strike’, Israel denies claim

French FM accuses Iran of carving out ‘axis’ of influence

Somali journalist killed in front of children

Over 170 dead after South Sudan rival cattle herders clash

Russia begins partial withdrawal from Syria

Russia weary of returning IS jihadists before World Cup, election

EU says Syria war ‘ongoing’ despite Russia pullout

Istanbul nightclub gunman refuses to testify

Integrating Syrians in Turkey carries implications

US opinion views Muslims and Arabs more favourably but political affiliation makes a difference

Iranian conservative protesters say Trump hastening end of Israel

Jordan referred to UN for failing to arrest Sudanese president

Turkey demands life for journalists in coup bid trial

Netanyahu expects EU to follow suit on Jerusalem

Putin orders withdrawal of ‘significant’ amount of troops from Syria

Putin to meet with Sisi in Cairo

GCC at a critical juncture

Houthi rebels tighten grip on Sanaa after Saleh’s assassination

Israel’s Syrian air strikes risk renewing escalation as Iran expands presence in Golan

Qatar to acquire 24 Typhoon fighters from UK

Bahraini civil society group criticised after Israel visit

Israel PM faces renewed pressure in Europe

Palestinian stabs Israeli guard in ‘terrorist’ attack

UAE’s Sheikh Mohammed says US Jerusalem decision could help terrorists

Fateh encourages more protests, refuses to meet Pence

Chinese electric carmaker to open Morocco factory

Iraqi victory over IS remains fragile

Morocco’s renewed ties with South Africa likely to consolidate support for Western Sahara stance

Lebanese security forces fire tear gas at protestors

Syria’s justice system: ‘working without a written law'

Egypt revives controversial desert capital project

Iran sentences fugitive ex-bank chief to jail

Iraq announces 'end of the war against Daesh'

Israeli air strike kills 2 in Gaza

UK foreign minister in Iran to push for Briton's release

Turkey's Erdogan seeks to lead Muslim response on Jerusalem

Iraqi Christians celebrate in town retaken from IS