First Published: 2009-01-07

 
Israeli propaganda takes international beating
 

Despite Israel’s propaganda campaigns on Gaza conflict, world public opinion remains critical of Tel Aviv.

 

Middle East Online

You can’t fool all the people all the time

TEL AVIV - Israel has taken a battering in the global media battle over its war on Gaza, despite deploying a propaganda campaign that used Youtube and blogs, experts said.

Populations and even governments worldwide have slammed the Israeli military onslaught on the Gaza Strip, with UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon condemning attacks near UN schools that killed dozens and foreign media angry at being kept out of the Palestinian territory.

With images of parents carrying lifeless children to overwhelmed hospitals dominating international media, angry protests have been staged in major capitals and Israeli websites have reportedly come under cyber attack.

European Union External Relations Commissioner Benita Ferrero-Waldner told President Shimon Peres in a meeting on Tuesday that "Israel's image is being destroyed" by its refusal to heed appeals for a ceasefire.

Hamas has been largely shunned by western media, but its plight – as the legitimate representatives of the Palestinian people in Gaza, the West Bank and even in East Jerusalem – is recognized by much of the world. .

Israel has sought to blame Hamas for its attacks on Gaza, ignoring the fact that Hamas was democratically elected by the Palestinians and that the people in Gaza know very well that Israel is the party behind their suffering.

But that fact is not commonly known in the West, where Israeli propaganda enjoys a large influence.

Israeli military spokeswoman Major Avital Liebovich and Israeli ambassadors have joined the television battle.

The defence ministry in Tel Aviv has posted videos of Israeli air strikes on Youtube, and the government has also tried to spur debates on Facebook.

But both sites are also a favorite of peace and humanitarian activists condemning Israeli policies long before Israel’s new offensive.

The Israeli consulate in New York this week organised a Twitter social networking debate on the merits of the war which drew more than 2,500 bloggers.

But blogs are the last place Israeli propaganda is expected to prevail, where they have long been used as a platform to expose Israeli ‘crimes’.

Israel says it will not let world public opinion sway the decision whether to call a ceasefire in the conflict that has left more than 680 Palestinians dead since December 27 -- a third of them children.

According to the president's office, Peres replied to Ferrero-Waldner: "We are not in the business of public relations or improving our image."

But experts say Peres tells a lie as Israel is doing all it can to present its war on the besieged Palestinian population in Gaza as an act of “self defense”.

Israel last year had hired a British public relations firm that had worked with Lebanon and the Northern Ireland governments on their image, experts say.

The Israelis "are the ones who have a grip on communications," said Dominique Wolton, a specialist on media at France's National Centre for Scientific Research (CNRS) in Paris.

"But Israel will not win the communications battle because whatever Israel's legitimate rights are, the unbalanced use of force and the unleashing of violence by Israel is acting against it.

"The Palestinians are not saying a lot. Israel has a grip on the communications and Israel manages its very well," Wolton commented. "The word 'terrorist' is systematically linked to Palestinians."

Charles Tripp, professor of Middle East politics at the School of Oriental and African Studies (SOAS) in London, said that in Europe, "the very powerful images of what's happening to civilians in Gaza must be having a greater impact than seeing Israeli spokesmen talking about the war on terror.

"In many ways, one of the main targets of the Israeli propaganda is Europe and the US, and I would have thought they're not doing too well there."

Meanwhile, two press rights groups Wednesday urged a media corridor in Gaza and called for Israel to allow journalists to work unfettered in the conflict zone.

Israel had blocked international journalists from entering Gaza. Israel had also bombed a Hamas-run TV station during its second day of raids against Gaza.


 

Damascus agrees ‘in principle’ to attend peace conference

Obama seeks to shape own political legacy

Algeria’s Belmokhtar brings terror to Niger

Egypt rulers reconcile with ex-regime tycoons

Secular Turkey curbs alcohol sales

US expands Iran sanctions blacklist

Deadly clashes in Lebanon's Tripoli continue unabated

Police make two further arrests in London soldier killing

Mali offensive opens Pandora’s Box: Qaeda offshoot spreads its wings

Darfur clashes displace 300,000 people in 5 months

Pepper spray charge: New episode in Tunisia Femen activist’s saga

Syria drags Lebanon into another Lebanese-Lebanese war

Mali Islamists take revenge on France in Niger

Khamenei’s recipe to secure his supreme rule: Limit presidential race to loyalists

Libyans in North Africa scared to return home

Syrian refugees head to Libya

Initiative of ‘Syrian origin’ offers Assad 'safe exit'

Cameron: Gruesome murder of British soldier is betrayal of Islam

Is Ennahda-led government waging a mock battle to distract Tunisians?

British FM: Mideast peace process urgent priority

Cloud of cynicism hangs over Kerry’s fourth visit to Israel

From secret to open role: More Nasrallah’s men die for Assad

Six killed in Lebanon’s Tripoli clashes

US acknowledges killing Awlaki

Friends of Syria to step up rebel aid if Assad fails to commit to peace

Mauritanian women denounce violence, rape

SARS-like virus claims another life in Saudi

'British soldier' beheaded in suspected Islamist attack

What is an Iranian drone doing in Bahrain, near Saudi Arabia?

Syria chemicals: ‘Mounting reports’ push UN to renew call for investigation

Ennahdha yields to Salafist pressure again: Ansar al-Sharia spokesman freed

New IAEA report reveals significant expansion of Iran nuclear capacity

EU approves civilian mission to help Libya tighten border security

Morsi seeks to assuage critics as pressure builds up in and outside Egypt

Hezbollah stokes fire of wide-scale civil war with role in Qusayr battle

Angry opposition suspends participation in Bahrain national dialogue

Iran distances itself from Saudi spy report

France sets aside millions of dollars to upgrade embassy security

Bouteflika’s heath: From news blackout to downpour of reassurances

12 killed in attack on Baghdad brothel

Qatar repeats Britain remarks to insist: Assad must step down!

Oman discusses US arms deal as it seeks to upgrade air defenses

Battle for strategic Qusayr: Opposition calls for rebel reinforcements

Iraq 'apologises' to Jordan over Saddam backers beating

Sectarian clashes rage in Lebanon's Tripoli