First Published: 2010-11-02


Saad Hariri’s Crisis Talks in London


International Tribunal on father’s murder may mean disaster for son, says Alexander Henley. The Tribunal has become a ball and chain that he drags with him to every negotiating table.


Middle East Online

Lebanese Prime Minister Saad Hariri is in London for talks with British counterpart David Cameron on the Special Tribunal for Lebanon, expected to indict Hezbollah members for the 2005 assassination of former PM Rafiq Hariri by the end of the year.

The tribunal is a ticking bomb that Saad Hariri’s government has been juggling for five years. The crisis came to a head last week with Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah’s call for a total boycott of the investigation.

Hezbollah's recent reception for Iranian President Ahmadinejad reminded the world that it has allies strong enough to stand up to America. Hariri's photo-shoot with British PM David Cameron on Monday represents the Lebanese leader picking up Hezbollah's gauntlet.

Since Nasrallah’s challenge, the cornered prime minister has been a blur of desperate action. His trip to London follows meetings with the Kuwaiti Emir and prime minister on Saturday. On the same day, US President Obama called the Saudi King to express his support for Hariri and the tribunal. Hariri’s next stop is expected to be Moscow.

The Lebanese National News Agency reports these trips vaguely as being "to discuss current affairs and bilateral relations". The precise content of Hariri’s talks with Western and pro-Western leaders will remain unclear, but we can assume he is doing all he can to shore up support abroad before the coming showdown with his domestic opposition.

Hariri cannot face off Hezbollah and its allies with military force, and possibly no longer with parliamentary weight. In time-honoured Lebanese tradition, Hariri's last resort is to internationalise the issue. On the domestic level he is weak, but if he can escalate it to the international arena, he may still come out on the winning side.

Certainly Obama and Cameron seem keen to champion the international tribunal in their struggle for “justice and democracy”. But it has not been the unswerving sword of independent justice they would have it seem.

Syria has brought charges of false testimony against tribunal collaborators. Perhaps more seriously, the investigators’ enquiries seem to have echoed US strategic priorities with eerie precision. In 2005, a time of UN sanctions against Syria as a “rogue state”, the evidence was hinted to lead to Syrian President Assad’s inner circle. The US and Israel’s more recent courting of Syria to isolate Iran was mirrored by reports that the tribunal would indict members of Hezbollah, Iran’s right hand in Lebanon.

The Special Tribunal for Lebanon has been a blessing and a curse for Saad Hariri: a political weapon that launched his political career but which he never quite controlled.

Saad Hariri has always lived in his father’s sizeable shadow. Rafiq was the very model of a self-made man, who turned “Hariri” into a household name. He moved to the Gulf to find his fortune in the mid-1960s, hit hard times, but came out on top in the late 1970s with several billion-dollar fortunes under his belt and friends in very high places.

Back in Lebanon, Rafiq distributed his wealth liberally through investment and philanthropic projects, winning – or buying, his critics would say – friends and voters in droves. Once the fifteen-year civil war was over – with a little help from Hariri Inc. – Rafiq emerged as a natural candidate for the premiership.

Saad Hariri was never a natural candidate for leadership, except by blood – and copious inheritance. When his father was murdered in a bomb attack on February 14, 2005, it was not clear whether the inexperienced son would step up. Such was the success of the March 14 “Cedar Revolution” against Syria, rousing the masses in the name of the martyred Rafiq Hariri, that Saad was swept into the new government.

The cause of the international tribunal was the government’s way of continually reminding the Lebanese of its achievements and moral high ground, even as it descended into rounds of political bickering. It also helped Saad Hariri to build on his father’s connections with Western leaders.

So dependent is Saad Hariri on his father’s legacy, however, that the tribunal has become a ball and chain that he drags with him to the negotiating table. He struggled with it during the long and difficult process of normalising relations with Syria, essential for political and economic stability in Lebanon. And it has caused him to stumble repeatedly in his dealings with Hezbollah, without whose support he can no longer govern.

The inevitable tick-tick of the tribunal’s final weeks has brought Saad Hariri’s premiership to crisis point amid fears of a renewed civil war with Hezbollah. Can he free himself from his commitment to justice for his father, or intimidate his opponents with shows of solidarity from Barack Obama and David Cameron? Or will the tribunal end Saad Hariri’s political career as it kick-started it five years ago?


Alexander D.M. Henley, PhD Candidate, University of Manchester


Russia airstrikes target ISIS infrastructure facilities in Syria

Israeli fire wounds at least 10 Palestinians in West Bank

Erdogan faces tough talks in meeting with EU leaders

UAE holds election for advisory council

Sohaib El Oussani reveals backstage of Europe Orient Documentary Film in Asilah

Erdogan urges Putin to reconsider air campaign in Syria

Iran expels Bahrain envoy in apparent retaliation

First hajj stampede bodies arrive in Iran from Saudi Arabia

US urges Libya rivals to move forward with peace deal

Powers condemn targeting of Syrian opposition by Russia

Turkey accuses Russia of hitting Syria rebels to bolster Assad

Palestinians kill Israeli couple in West Bank shooting

Russia again strikes Assad regime's foes

Iran backs Russian military strategy in Syria

S&P: Gulf banks' net earnings set to slide

Russia confirms new air strikes on targets in Syria

12 killed in Ankara bus stop crash

Syrians, Afghans clash in German refugee centre

South Sudan's peace deal means little in Koch swamps

Trump: If I’m elected, Syrians go back home!

Iran says 464 dead in Saudi hajj stampede

Saudi, Iran agree to repatriate dead pilgrims

Abbas: Palestinians no longer feel bound by past agreements with Israel

Russia, US to hold ‘de-confliction’ talks on Syria

Three conditions as France voices concern over Russia involvement in Syria

Iraq Kurdish forces recapture land from ISIS jihadists

Tunisia buries Sousse gunman under strict security cordon

Iran diplomat missing after hajj stampede

Six days after hajj tragedy, Iran-Saudi tensions escalate

For first time in history, Palestinians to raise flag at UN

Finland freezes asylum decisions for Iraq, Somalia refugees

UK Labour Party ready to support Syria airstrikes, with conditions

Iran Foreign Minister under fire over ‘Obama handshake’

Parliamentary and religious support as Russia launches airstrikes in Syria

Assad regime strikes kill 27 civilians in central Syria

Iraq kidnappers free remaining 16 Turkish workers

Iran threatens 'fierce' reaction if Saudi Arabia does not repatriate hajj victims

Damascus confirms Assad request for military aid from Russia

Europe refugee crisis in focus at UN

France launches war crimes inquiry against Syria regime

Coalition seizes Iran boat with arms for Yemen rebels

Putin gets unanimous parliament support for Syria air strikes

Morocco government blocks opening of first Ikea

Israeli air raids hit Gaza in response to rocket fire

Saudi FM insists Assad must go or be ousted