First Published: 2012-05-21


Video exposes Israeli troops’ indifference towards settlers’ violence


Israeli army is investigating incident that was exposed by video clips in which troops appeared to stand by without intervening as settlers shot at Palestinians.


Middle East Online

Are there limits to Israeli settlers’ impunity?

JERUSALEM - The Israeli army said on Monday it was investigating an incident that was exposed by two video clips in which troops appeared to stand by without intervening as settlers shot at Palestinians.

The shooting incident took place on Saturday afternoon during stone-throwing clashes between settlers from the hardline Yitzhar settlement and Palestinian villagers from Asira al-Qibliya near Nablus.

The footage, which shows a Palestinian being shot by two settlers in the presence of at least three soldiers, was captured by a volunteer for the Israeli human rights group B'Tselem.

The apparent indifference of the soldiers was widely covered by the Israeli press and was condemned by the Palestinian government in Ramallah.

In response, the army said troops had arrived at the scene to break up a violent confrontation in which both sides were throwing stones at each other.

"During the confrontation, live fire was used; the incident is currently being investigated by the division commander," a military statement said.

"That said, it appears that the video in question does not reflect the incident in its entirety," it added, without elaborating.

In one of the clips, two settlers with M-16 assault rifles can be seen opening fire at a stone-thrower in a green shirt who collapses onto the ground after being hit in the head.

In the second clip from a slightly different angle, a third settler can be seen firing with a pistol towards the stonethrowers as three soldiers stand close by doing nothing.

B'Tselem filed a complaint with the police, urging them to prosecute the gunmen, and also with the military police calling for an investigation into suspicions the soldiers "did not adhere to their obligation to protect Palestinians from settler violence."

"The video footage raises grave suspicions that the soldiers present did not act to prevent the settlers from throwing stones and firing live ammunition at the Palestinians," the rights group said in a statement late on Sunday.

"The soldiers did not try to remove the settlers and in fact are seen standing by settlers while they are shooting and stone throwing."

The Palestinian Authority called on Israel to treat the incident "seriously and to open a fair investigation to bring the assailants to justice."

"The gravity of the footage lies not only in the settlers' provocations and shooting live ammunition towards unarmed residents, but also in the irresponsibility of the Israeli soldiers who stood watching the events without trying to stop the settlers," a statement said.

And it urged the international community to pressure Israel "to act firmly and promptly against the settlers' extremism, their deadly attacks, and the incitement against the Palestinians."

Palestinian witnesses said the incident occurred when dozens of settlers attacked the village throwing stones and provoking residents who threw stones back.

But Yitzhar spokesman Avraham Binyamin said the incident began when the settlement's emergency response team, which had gone to put out fires "lit by Asira residents," was attacked by "hundreds of rioters who threw stones at them."

He said the footage accurately showed the "barrage of stones at the emergency response team, while they were shielding the firefighters, two of whom were wounded by stones earlier in the event."

He said it was "obvious" that the team had only used weapons as the result of "a life-endangering situation."

The two video clips can be seen on: and


Nobel Peace Prize goes to Tunisian democracy group

UN envoy proposes Libya unity government led by Sarraj

Iran Revolutionary Guards commander killed in Syria

IS militants advance on Syria's Aleppo

Russian volunteers fighting for Assad regime

UN chief hails Tunisian Nobel Peace Prize

Israeli troops kill 4 near Gaza border as Hamas praises 'Jerusalem intifada'

US to 'refocus' failed Syrian rebel training programme

France carries out second wave of strikes on IS targets in Syria

Jew stabs four Arabs in southern Israel

At least 13 killed in Yemen wedding bombing

Three more stabbing attacks as Palestine-Israel violence continues

Violence in Jerusalem continues

Turkey gives EU's migrant plan offer lukewarm reception

Erdogan uses nuclear, gas deals to pressure Russia over Syria

HRW urges statement from West over imprisoned Bahrain dissidents

EU aim to have migrant 'hotspots' ready by end of November ‘unrealistic’

Israeli PM bars ministers from Al-Aqsa compound

US has not yet made decision on Syria no-fly zone

After nuclear deal, Iran takes central role to end Syria war

Escape or temporary move: Erdogan son settles in Italy

ISIS attack complicates task for Arab coalition in Yemen

Syria army launches broad ground operation in Hama province

Israel-Palestinian unrest at risk of turning into religious war

Number of confirmed cholera cases rises to 1,200 in Iraq

Russia ‘ready’ to establish contacts with Free Syrian Army

Turkey arrests six people over 'minting coins for ISIS’

US insists no military cooperation with Russia in Syria conflict

Russia warships fire cruise missiles to back Syria army operation

New violence rocks Israel, West Bank

Mortar attack wounds Lebanon soldiers near border with Syria

Iraq forces recapture several areas around Ramadi

Saleh’s party ‘ready’ for UN-brokered Yemen peace

Erdogan’s vision of Syria’s future torn up by Putin

IS bombings will not deter Yemen govt from staying in Aden

EU to ease Turkey migrant burden on conditions

EU kicks off military operation against ‘mafia of the sea’

Russia air strikes targeting Chechen jihadists in Syria

Russia examining US proposals to coordinate Syria strikes

Russia hints at willingness on Syria 'deconfliction' with US

France may strip five terrorists of nationality

Israel demolition policy: Collective punishment in violation of international law

Violence in Yemen may trigger world's next great refugee crisis

EU to 'step up' work on resettlement of refugees from Turkey

Tunisia dismantles three ISIS recruitment cells